Savings rates are variable, and the forces behind them explain both the pleasant surprises and the disappointing letters.
The biggest force is the Federal Reserve. When the central bank raises its policy rate, banks earn more on the cash deposited with them, and the competitive ones pass a share of that through to savers. When the policy rate falls, savings rates follow it down - usually faster than they climbed.
The second force is a bank’s own appetite for deposits. A bank funding a growing loan book bids for your cash with a stronger rate; a bank already flush with deposits lets its rate drift. This is why the leaderboard of top-paying accounts reshuffles constantly, and why the strongest payer of one season is often mid-table by the next.
The third force is structure: balance tiers, relationship pricing that rewards linked accounts, and promotional windows built to win switchers. Put together, the lesson is simple. The rate you open with is a snapshot, not a standing offer - a bank is free to reprice it the day after you arrive, and over a long enough holding period most eventually do. The terms around it - federal insurance, access rules, fees - are the stable part of the deal, and they are the part worth choosing on.